Skip to content
Home » Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time

Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time

  • by

Imagine if you had a special time machine that could take you back in history. You would have the chance to learn about the way the United States government treated Native American tribes throughout the years. This article, called “Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time”, will take you on a fascinating journey through different periods of history to see how these policies changed. So get ready to travel through time and learn all about the important topic of Indian policy in the United States!

Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time

This image is property of



Introduction to United States Indian Policy

United States Indian Policy refers to the various approaches, laws, and actions taken by the United States government towards Native American tribes and communities throughout history. It is essential to understand the context of these policies and their impact on Native American communities.

Historical Context of Indian Policy

Indian policy in the United States has a deep historical context, rooted in the arrival of European colonizers and their interactions with Native American tribes. When Europeans first arrived in the Americas, they encountered a diverse array of Native American cultures, languages, and governing systems. As the United States expanded westward, the relationship between the US government and Native American tribes evolved and often shifted power dynamics.

Termination Era

Definition and Objectives of Termination Policy

The Termination Era, which took place from the mid-1940s to the mid-1960s, refers to a policy approach that sought to “terminate” the status of Native American tribes as federally recognized sovereign nations. The objectives of this policy were to assimilate Native Americans into mainstream American society, abolish reservations, and eliminate federal responsibility for providing services such as healthcare and education to Native American communities.

Impact of Termination on Native American Communities

The Termination Era had devastating consequences for Native American communities. Many tribes lost their land, cultural identity, and access to vital resources. The forced assimilation into mainstream society disrupted traditional ways of life and contributed to the erosion of Native American languages, practices, and traditions. Additionally, the termination policy led to economic instability, poverty, and social dislocation among Native American communities.

Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time

This image is property of


Self-Determination Era

Introduction to Self-Determination Policy

The Self-Determination Era, which began in the late 1960s, marked a significant shift in United States Indian Policy. This era recognized the inherent sovereignty of Native American tribes and aimed to empower them to exercise self-governance and make decisions regarding their own affairs.

Tribal Sovereignty and Self-Governance

Tribal sovereignty refers to the inherent authority of Native American tribes to govern themselves and make decisions regarding their own lands, people, and resources. The Self-Determination Era aimed to strengthen tribal sovereignty and grant Native American tribes greater control over their destinies. This included the ability to manage tribal lands, develop economic enterprises, and maintain tribal cultural practices and traditions.

Creation of Indian Self-Determination Policy

The Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 was a pivotal moment in United States Indian Policy. This legislation enabled Native American tribes to enter into self-determination contracts with the federal government, allowing them to assume control over certain governmental programs and services previously administered by federal agencies. This shift towards self-governance aimed to improve the delivery of services to Native American communities while preserving their cultural identity and traditions.

Relocation Era

Overview of Relocation Policy

The Relocation Era, which took place from the 1940s to the 1960s, involved the forced relocation of thousands of Native Americans from their tribal lands to urban areas, primarily in cities like Los Angeles, Chicago, and Minneapolis. The relocation policy was implemented primarily to assimilate Native Americans into mainstream American culture and provide them with employment opportunities.

Causes and Motivations for Relocation

Several factors contributed to the implementation of the relocation policy. One key factor was the urbanization and industrialization occurring in the United States during this period, resulting in a demand for cheap labor. Another motivation was the belief that Native Americans would benefit from assimilation into mainstream society, accessing better education, healthcare, and employment opportunities.

Consequences of Relocation on Native Americans

Relocation had significant consequences for Native American communities. Many faced difficulties adjusting to unfamiliar urban environments and experienced discrimination, poverty, and cultural dislocation. The separation from their tribal lands and traditions led to the loss of cultural identity and a profound impact on Native American communities’ social fabric.

Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time

This image is property of


Assimilation Era

Assimilation Policy and Its Goals

The Assimilation Era spanned from the late 19th century into the mid-20th century. This policy aimed to eradicate Native American cultures, languages, and traditions by forcing assimilation into mainstream American society. The overarching goal was to transform Native Americans into “civilized” citizens according to Western ideals.

Forced Assimilation Methods and Strategies

Many strategies were used during the Assimilation Era to enforce assimilation. Native American children were often forcibly removed from their families and placed in boarding schools where they were prohibited from speaking their native languages or practicing their cultural traditions. Additionally, cultural practices, such as traditional ceremonies and religious rituals, were actively suppressed.

Impact of Assimilation on Native American Identity

The Assimilation Era had a profound impact on Native American identity. Generations of Native Americans grew up disconnected from their cultural heritage, facing a loss of language, traditions, and values. This loss of identity contributed to intergenerational trauma, as well as challenges in reclaiming and revitalizing Native American cultures in contemporary times.

Reservation Era

Emergence and Development of Reservation Policy

The Reservation Era began in the mid-19th century with the establishment of reservations as designated areas for Native American tribes to live. Initially, reservations were seen as a temporary solution, but they ultimately became a permanent aspect of federal Indian policy. The goal was to confine Native Americans to specific lands and enable the federal government to control and assimilate them.

Government-Provided Services in Reservations

The federal government provided various services to tribes residing on reservations, such as education, healthcare, and access to basic necessities. However, these services often fell short of meeting the needs of Native American communities and were subject to bureaucratic inefficiencies and underfunding. As a result, many reservations experienced inadequate infrastructure, limited economic opportunities, and healthcare disparities.

Challenges and Issues Faced by Reservations

Reservations face numerous challenges and issues. Persistent poverty, high unemployment rates, and limited access to quality education and healthcare remain prevalent on many reservations. Furthermore, the historical loss of land and resources, coupled with systemic inequities, creates barriers to economic development and hinders the self-determination and sovereignty of Native American tribes.

Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time

Land Policies and Treaties

Overview of Land Policies and Treaties

Land policies and treaties have played a critical role in shaping the relationship between the United States government and Native American tribes. The policies and treaties were instrumental in facilitating land acquisitions by the United States and outlining the rights of Native American tribes while often disregarding their inherent sovereignty and traditional land tenure systems.

Implications and Outcomes of Land Policies

The implementation of land policies often resulted in the forced removal of Native American tribes from their ancestral territories. The loss of land, which held both cultural and economic significance, disrupted traditional lifestyles and contributed to a loss of self-sufficiency and cultural identity. Additionally, the allocation of reservation lands often proved insufficient to meet the needs of growing populations, exacerbating economic disparities and resource constraints.

Impact of Treaties on Native American Tribes

Treaties between Native American tribes and the United States government have had a lasting impact on tribal sovereignty and the recognition of tribal rights. However, many treaties were often violated or abrogated, leading to a further erosion of tribal autonomy and land rights. The ongoing effects of broken treaties contribute to persisting struggles for Native American communities seeking redress, land restoration, and the preservation of cultural heritage.

Impact on Native American communities

Social, Economic, and Cultural Effects on Native Americans

The United States Indian Policy has had significant social, economic, and cultural effects on Native American communities. Socially, Native Americans have faced discrimination, stereotypes, and the loss of traditional cultural practices due to forced assimilation. Economically, many Native American communities experience higher poverty rates and limited economic opportunities compared to mainstream society. Culturally, intergenerational trauma resulting from historical policies has impacted the preservation and revitalization of Native American languages, traditions, and identities.

Intergenerational Trauma and Loss of Land and Resources

Intergenerational trauma refers to the transmission of historical trauma and its psychological and emotional impacts across generations. Native American communities have experienced intergenerational trauma as a result of the loss of land, forced assimilation, and other destructive policies. Additionally, the loss of land and resources has limited the economic opportunities and self-sufficiency of Native American tribes, perpetuating cycles of poverty and dependency.

Efforts of Native American Communities to Preserve Culture

Despite the challenges they face, Native American communities have demonstrated resilience and agency in preserving their cultures. Many tribes engage in cultural revitalization initiatives, including language preservation, traditional arts and crafts, and intergenerational storytelling. Native American communities also strive to address historical injustices through advocacy, legal actions, and initiatives that seek to restore land and resources, improve healthcare and education, and promote self-determination.

Examining United States Indian Policy Over Time

Contemporary Perspectives

Current United States Indian Policy

Current United States Indian Policy focuses on recognizing and affirming tribal sovereignty, self-governance, and the government-to-government relationship between federal agencies and Native American tribes. The policy aims to support Native American tribes in addressing social, economic, and political challenges while fostering cultural preservation and self-determination.

Efforts Toward Tribal Sovereignty

Efforts toward tribal sovereignty involve strengthening tribal self-governance and decision-making authority. This includes the development of tribal justice systems, educational curricula, and cultural preservation programs that reflect Native American values, languages, and traditions.

Collaboration and Partnerships with Native American Tribes

Collaboration and partnerships between the federal government and Native American tribes are essential for addressing the challenges faced by Native American communities. This may involve joint initiatives to improve education, healthcare, economic development opportunities, environmental conservation, and the preservation of cultural heritage.

Critiques and Reforms

Problems and Injustices in United States Indian Policy

United States Indian Policy has faced numerous critiques for perpetuating historical injustices and systemic inequities. Many argue that policies have failed to adequately address the historical trauma experienced by Native American communities and the ongoing challenges they face in areas such as healthcare, education, and economic development. The lack of sufficient funding, bureaucratic hurdles, and insufficient consultation with tribal leaders are among the key issues raised.

Calls for Policy Reforms and Redress

Calls for policy reforms and redress highlight the need to rectify historical injustices and address ongoing disparities. These reforms include increased funding for healthcare and education programs, strengthening tribal sovereignty and self-governance, and honoring treaty rights. Additionally, there are demands for greater inclusion of Native American voices in policy discussions and decision-making processes.

Efforts towards Restorative Justice

Efforts towards restorative justice involve recognizing and addressing the historical trauma experienced by Native American communities. This includes initiatives to restore lands, resources, and sacred sites to tribes, establishing truth and reconciliation commissions, and supporting community-led healing and revitalization initiatives. Restorative justice approaches aim to promote healing, reconciliation, and the empowerment of Native American communities.


Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading